Mallory and Irvine: The 1924 Everest Mystery
Two Englishmen vanished near Everest's summit in 1924. The 1999 body, a 2024 boot, the missing camera and the Second Step — what the evidence shows.
NepGem team · Local guides and trip planners
· 15 min read

George Mallory and Andrew Irvine were last seen alive at around 12:50 pm on 8 June 1924, high on the north-east ridge of Everest, moving well toward the summit. Neither man came back down. Whether they stood on top twenty-nine years before the first ascent of Everest is the oldest unresolved question in mountaineering, and it is still unresolved: no photograph, no summit note and no witness account places either man above the ridge's hardest obstacle, a rock band called the Second Step. This article does not retell the romantic version of the story. It sets out exactly what one witness saw through drifting cloud for a few seconds, what was found on Mallory's body in 1999, what a 2024 discovery added, what the physical evidence for and against a summit actually is, and why most historians who have studied the case closely conclude, carefully, that the balance currently tips against them without ruling it out entirely.
The last sighting, 12:50 pm, 8 June 1924
The only eyewitness account of Mallory and Irvine above their final camp comes from Noel Odell, a geologist and support climber who glimpsed them for a few seconds through cloud shortly before 1 pm on 8 June 1924, and even that account is disputed in its details. Odell was climbing alone below the pair, ferrying oxygen cylinders and hunting for fossils, when the cloud briefly cleared. He later described "one tiny black spot" silhouetted against a snow-crest below a rock step, then a second spot moving up to join it; the first "approached the great rock-step and shortly emerged at the top," and the second did the same shortly after. Odell judged the pair to be "going strong for the top" and in good time to reach the summit and return before dark.
The trouble is which rock step Odell actually meant. The north-east ridge has three named rock bands: the First Step at roughly 8,564 m, the Second Step at roughly 8,610 m, and a smaller Third Step above it. Odell's own account shifted over the years he was asked to recall it, and expedition members and later historians have argued the case in both directions using his description of light, shadow and the shape of the skyline. If Odell saw them nearing the Second Step at 12:50 pm, they were on a pace that could plausibly reach the summit; if what he actually saw was the lower and easier First Step, they were running roughly an hour or more behind the schedule they would have needed to summit and descend safely in daylight. Odell called out and waited, then continued alone before eventually descending to report that the two men had not returned. His account, published as "Mr Odell's Story" in the Alpine Journal later that year, remains the entire eyewitness record of what happened above their high camp. Everything else in this article is inference from equipment, timing and terrain, not testimony.
Who they were
George Leigh Mallory was 37 in 1924, an English schoolmaster and veteran of both previous British Everest expeditions: the 1921 reconnaissance, which first mapped an approach to the mountain, and the 1922 attempt, on which he climbed with supplemental oxygen for the first time and reached over 8,300 m. He was already a public figure in Britain and the United States by 1924, having lectured widely on the mountain, and it was on that American lecture tour in 1923 that a New York Times reporter asked him why he wanted to climb Everest. His recorded answer, "Because it's there," ran in the paper on 18 March 1923 and became the most quoted line in mountaineering history, though several biographers have since noted that Mallory's actual answer to the reporter was longer and more considered, and that the three-word version may owe as much to a sub-editor's pen as to Mallory himself. He carried a photograph of his wife, Ruth, on the 1924 expedition, telling teammates he intended to leave it on the summit.
Andrew "Sandy" Irvine was 22, an Oxford undergraduate with comparatively little mountaineering experience, and Mallory's choice of him as a partner over more seasoned climbers on the expedition has been debated ever since. What Irvine brought was mechanical skill: the expedition's oxygen sets were fragile and prone to leaking or icing, and Irvine had already redesigned and repaired the apparatus during the approach march, work the whole team depended on. The expedition itself was led by Edward Norton, who had reached roughly 8,570 m without supplemental oxygen just four days before Mallory and Irvine's attempt, a height record that stood for more than fifty years. It approached from Tibet, since Nepal was closed to foreign travel at the time, and it was the third British attempt on the mountain in four years. The north-east ridge line they were climbing is one of several established everest climbing routes still in use today, though the vast majority of modern climbers now approach from the south, via Nepal, rather than retracing the 1924 party's line from Tibet.
The evidence for
Three pieces of physical and circumstantial evidence are cited by those who believe Mallory and Irvine may have reached the top, and each is genuinely suggestive without being conclusive. First, when Mallory's body was found in 1999, his snow goggles were folded in a pocket rather than on his face. Because climbers on that ridge only need goggles in daylight, some researchers read this as evidence that he was still moving, and therefore alive, after dark, which would only make sense if the pair had already made their summit attempt and were descending late rather than dying on the way up in daylight.
Second, the photograph of Ruth that Mallory said he would leave on the summit was not found among his effects in 1999. Its absence is consistent with him having reached the top and left it there, but it is equally consistent with the photograph being lost during the fatal fall, left behind at a lower camp, or simply not carried that day; an absence proves nothing on its own; it only fits one interpretation better than others.
Third, Odell's own account of their pace before 12:50 pm is genuinely fast for two men that high on the mountain, and the rope fragment recovered around Mallory's waist in 1999 shows a clean break consistent with a shared fall rather than a solo collapse, meaning the two men were almost certainly still together, and still moving as a team, at the point something went wrong. None of this places either man above the Second Step. It establishes that they were high, moving with purpose, and together when the accident happened, which keeps a summit push plausible without making it demonstrated.
The evidence against
The strongest argument against a summit rests on a single feature: the Second Step, a near-vertical rock band at roughly 8,610 m that stood unclimbed without artificial aid for thirty-six years after Mallory and Irvine disappeared. The first confirmed ascent of the step came in 1960, when a Chinese expedition's lead climber removed his boots and gloves, stood on a teammate's shoulders and then his head, and hauled himself over the top, suffering severe frostbite in the process. In 1975, a second Chinese expedition fixed an aluminium ladder to the step, which has been used by nearly every climber on the route since and was replaced with a new one in 2007. In 1924, Mallory and Irvine had hobnailed leather boots, hemp rope and no ladder. Most climbers and historians who have examined the step in person regard free-climbing it, at that altitude, in that gear, exhausted and without modern technique, as a formidable obstacle and possibly beyond what either man could have managed and still had the strength to descend.
The oxygen arithmetic points the same way. Their sets carried a fixed, limited supply, and historians who have modelled plausible consumption rates against the known cylinder capacity and the time elapsed since their last confirmed resupply argue the two men would have been running low on supplemental oxygen well before a round trip to the summit and back could have been completed, forcing a slow, oxygen-starved retreat through the altitude band above 8,000 m now known as the death zone. Finally, several analysts have tried to reconstruct the lighting conditions in Odell's account using the sun's known position at that time and location on 8 June 1924, and more than one such reconstruction favours the lower, easier First Step as the feature he actually saw, which would put the pair roughly an hour behind the pace needed for a safe summit and return. No one who has studied the case doubts that Mallory and Irvine were extraordinarily capable climbers for their era. The disagreement is over whether extraordinary capability was enough to overcome a specific, dateable technical obstacle with 1924 equipment, and on that narrower question the physical evidence leans against them.
| Evidence for a summit | Evidence against a summit | |
|---|---|---|
| Goggles | Found in pocket, suggesting a night descent after a summit attempt | Could simply mean he removed them in cloud or low light before the accident |
| Ruth's photograph | Missing from his effects, consistent with leaving it at the top | Equally consistent with loss during the fall or being left lower down |
| Pace at 12:50 pm | Odell judged them "going strong," on schedule | Sun-angle analysis of the same sighting favours a lower, slower position |
| The Second Step | Skilled climbers, strong tradition of underestimating them | Unclimbed without aid until 1960, laddered since 1975 |
| Oxygen supply | Sets could be conserved or shared between the pair | Modelled consumption suggests a round trip was not feasible on the gas carried |
1999: finding Mallory
Mallory's body was located on 1 May 1999 by a dedicated research expedition, the Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition led by Eric Simonson, when climber Conrad Anker found him lying face-down on a scree terrace at roughly 8,155 m on Everest's north face. The search had been motivated for decades by a secondhand clue: in 1975, a Chinese climber named Wang Hongbao reportedly told a teammate he had found "an old English dead" nearby, then died in an avalanche the following day before he could give more detail. Anker's discovery, seventy-five years after the disappearance, confirmed the story was true.
The body was remarkably well preserved by the cold, dry air at that altitude. A rope fragment was tied around the waist, its frayed end consistent with a shared fall that separated him from a companion, almost certainly Irvine. Name tapes sewn into his clothing, reading "G. Leigh Mallory," confirmed the identification beyond doubt. His effects included an altimeter, a pocketknife, monogrammed handkerchiefs and a letter, along with the folded snow goggles discussed above. There was no camera. The 1999 team gave Mallory a burial in accordance with Church of England rite at the site and, at the family's request, kept the most graphic photographs of the discovery out of public circulation. Anker and journalist David Roberts later wrote up the search and the find in full in "The Lost Explorer: Finding Mallory on Mount Everest."
The 1999 discovery answered some questions and left the central one untouched. It confirmed that Mallory fell, roped to a partner, on the descent side of a route that placed his final resting point below where the pair were last seen; it gave researchers physical evidence to model against the oxygen and equipment questions above. It found nothing, however, that placed him above the Second Step, and nothing resembling a summit photograph, note or marker. For the question the whole search exists to answer, the 1999 expedition ended in the same place it began: no proof, and a stronger circumstantial case than before.
The camera
Mallory carried a Vest Pocket Kodak camera, a compact folding model common among the 1924 expedition's members, and it was not among his effects when his body was found in 1999. Researchers, including Holzel and Salkeld, have long argued that Irvine, not Mallory, was most likely carrying the camera at the time of the accident, since expedition members typically shared the load of equipment between a climbing pair. Kodak's own technical assessments over the years have suggested that unexposed film from that era, kept for decades in the cold, dry, low-oxygen conditions of Everest's high north face, could in principle still be developed, though the process would be delicate and untested at anything close to this timescale, and nobody knows what condition any surviving film would actually be in.
In September 2024, a National Geographic documentary team led by climber Jimmy Chin found a boot and an attached sock on the Central Rongbuk Glacier, well below where Mallory's body had been located, with a tag sewn into the sock reading "A.C. Irvine." At the time of the most recent public reporting, DNA comparison with Irvine's living relatives was underway to confirm the identification, and no camera was found with the remains. If Irvine's camera is eventually located and its film can be developed, a clear image showing summit-identifying terrain, or the two men together above the Second Step, would settle the question outright. Equally, blank or fogged film would settle nothing at all. As things stand, the camera remains the one piece of physical evidence that could end the argument, and it is still missing.
What a historian would conclude
Read plainly, the balance of evidence available today leans against Mallory and Irvine having reached the summit, though it does not rule a summit out. It is worth remembering that even the basic fact of how tall Everest is, 8,848.86 m, was not fixed by a joint, satellite-grade survey until 2020; a mountain whose exact height took a century to agree on has never made this kind of question easy to close. The Second Step stood unclimbed without artificial aid until 1960 and was not made routinely passable until a ladder was fixed in 1975; the modelled oxygen supply does not comfortably support a round trip from where they were last seen; and more than one attempt to reconstruct the lighting in Odell's account favours the lower, easier of the two features he might have seen. Set against that is a body of circumstantial detail, the goggles, the missing photograph, the fast pace Odell described, that keeps the question genuinely open rather than closed.
What would close it is either Irvine's camera, recovered with developable film showing unambiguous evidence of a summit, or new physical evidence higher on the route than anything found so far. Until one of those things happens, the verifiable historical record stands as it has for a century: the first confirmed ascent of Everest was achieved by Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay on 29 May 1953, and Mallory and Irvine's fate above 8,000 m remains, honestly, unknown.
FAQ
Did Mallory and Irvine reach the summit of Everest? Probably not, on the current balance of evidence, though the question remains formally open. The Second Step was unclimbed without artificial aid until 1960 and modelled oxygen supplies suggest a round trip was difficult, but no direct evidence rules a summit out entirely, and researchers continue to search for proof either way.
Was Mallory's body found? Yes. A research expedition led by Eric Simonson found Mallory's body on 1 May 1999 at roughly 8,155 m on Everest's north face, discovered by climber Conrad Anker. Name tapes sewn into his clothing confirmed the identification, and the team buried him at the site in accordance with Church of England rite.
Has Irvine been found? Possibly. In September 2024, a National Geographic team found a boot and sock bearing the tag "A.C. Irvine" on the Central Rongbuk Glacier, lower than where Mallory's body lay. DNA comparison with Irvine's family was underway as of the most recent reporting, and no camera was recovered with the remains.
Did Mallory say "because it's there"? Yes, according to a New York Times report from 18 March 1923, when a reporter asked why he wanted to climb Everest. Several biographers note his actual answer was longer and more considered, and the memorable three-word version may have been shaped by the reporter or an editor rather than spoken exactly as written.
Trek to where the mystery still unfolds
You do not need a 1920s wool jacket, hobnailed boots or a place in the history books to stand where this story is still being written. Mallory and Irvine's route lay on Everest's Tibetan north side, but the modern view across at that same north ridge silhouette, the one Odell watched through drifting cloud in 1924, is exactly what you get from Kala Patthar and the high passes on Nepal's south-side routes. Planning that trip alone is more logistics than most people want to take on solo. NepGem's curated Everest region group departures let you arrive by yourself and trek with people who are already booked on the same dates, with the shared costs, the guide's fee, the jeep, the permits, split across everyone on the departure rather than carried by one traveller. Join a group that already has people on it, and let someone else's planning carry you as far as base camp.
Sources
- Conrad Anker and David Roberts, The Lost Explorer: Finding Mallory on Mount Everest (Simon & Schuster, 1999).
- Tom Holzel and Audrey Salkeld, First on Everest: The Mystery of Mallory and Irvine (Henry Holt and Company, 1986; revised editions to 1999).
- Noel Odell, "Mr Odell's Story," Alpine Journal, vol. 36, no. 229 (November 1924).
- National Geographic, reporting on the September 2024 discovery of a boot and sock identified with Andrew Irvine on the Central Rongbuk Glacier (October 2024).


